THERE ARE ALL sorts of reasons for wanting to like this album. Shall I count them?
1) Tikao seems to want to make her Maori ancestry a living thing by presenting some of her songs in Te Reo, and using Maori instruments wherever they’re a good fit.
2) She takes the gift of song seriously, writing about things both close to her heart and concepts that she finds meaningful.
3) She was clearly personally devastated by the Christchurch earthquakes in 2010 and 2011 (she hails from the southern city, though now resides in Wellington), has been involved in the emotional rebuild, and the album was ‘inspired’ (possibly a poor choice of words) by those events.
4) She comes across as sincere.
Albums are made for listening, however, and when the music itself doesn’t ever quite convince, there’s no getting around that fact.
The 11 songs on From Dust To Light, her third album, are pleasant enough; but there’s no escaping the mumsiness of her vocal delivery, or some of the terrible lyric writing. Try this for size: ‘Hate me for leaving/But like a fundamental truth I must go.” It may have been preferable if she’d stuck to Te Reo for the whole project, but then we’d still have to read song descriptions like this: “I was inspired by watching a tui feed off the nectar of a kowhai tree in bloom.” It’s not that the sentiment is wrong here, it’s the need to write it down at all.
While the Maori instruments add to the atmospheres, most of the songs are gently guitar-picked and folk-flavoured and accompanied by low-key contributions by Lee Prebble (who helped to produce the album), Charlie Davenport (cello) and Leyton (electronics). But whatever magic is hinted at in the music is quickly brought down to earth by the singer’s clunky vocal style, and songs that are, at best, slight. GARY STEEL
Music = 2.5/5
Sound = 3.5/5
Ariana Tikao – From Dust To Light (Independent) CD REVIEW
Latest from Music
Aldous Harding: The lost interview
Especially for New Zealand Music Month GARY STEEL disinters a 10-year-old interview with Aldous Harding conducted at the time of her debut album.
1001 Albums You Must Die Before You Hear – The Small Faces
MATT KELLY is aghast at how far this formerly great band had fallen by the time of its reunion albums and explains their sad
Icehouse, 40 years ago
It’s not often you get to interview Iva Davies (Icehouse) and Jo Camilleri (Jo Jo Zep) at the same time. GARY STEEL did way
Hi-Fi Show Report: AXPONA
OWEN HARRIS moseyed along to the largest hi-fi show in the USA and instead of just taking in endless rooms of product took time
Random Vinyl Play: This 1969 debut is an unheralded classic
In a new column, GARY STEEL dips into his vinyl racks. Today it’s the tasty debut by UK psychedelic band Caravan.