THIS IS GOING to sound ridiculous, but I’ll say it anyway: I reckon Sharon Van Etten grew up listening to the Mamas and the Papas, as her full-bodied and beautifully expressive vocals have something of Mama Cass’s sweep and tonal range. And that’s a compliment.
Tramp, however, sounds nothing like the Mamas and the Papas’ slick folk-rock. Even when she cuts things back to a semi-acoustic folk style, there’s a rawness in the instrumentation that keeps it sounding real. Which isn’t to say that it’s not exquisitely crafted, because it is; just that a lot of the time, electric guitar is allowed to fly, unfettered, and it always sounds more or less live-in-studio.
It’s her third album, and is produced by The National’s Aaron Dessner, and it’s fair to say that there is a touch of the folk-rock craft that band brings to its own projects.
But Van Etten is really a kind of diva in folk-rock clothing, and it’s her voice that’s really captivating – so much so that I forgot to listen to what she was singing, because I was wrapped up in the dramatic power of her delivery. Although she never gets into the kind of epiglottal acrobatics of a Jeff Buckley, she does have a trill to her voice that reminds me of that transcendental singer, and an instinctive awareness of where to accent a note. Just like the music itself, her voice is both sweet and sour, and capable of navigating the unusual melodic twists and turns she constructs for it.
In short, Tramp is a breath of fresh air. GARY STEEL
Music = 4/5
Sound = 4/5
Latest from Music
Aldous Harding: The lost interview
Especially for New Zealand Music Month GARY STEEL disinters a 10-year-old interview with Aldous Harding conducted at the time of her debut album.
1001 Albums You Must Die Before You Hear – The Small Faces
MATT KELLY is aghast at how far this formerly great band had fallen by the time of its reunion albums and explains their sad
Icehouse, 40 years ago
It’s not often you get to interview Iva Davies (Icehouse) and Jo Camilleri (Jo Jo Zep) at the same time. GARY STEEL did way
Hi-Fi Show Report: AXPONA
OWEN HARRIS moseyed along to the largest hi-fi show in the USA and instead of just taking in endless rooms of product took time
Random Vinyl Play: This 1969 debut is an unheralded classic
In a new column, GARY STEEL dips into his vinyl racks. Today it’s the tasty debut by UK psychedelic band Caravan.