Carnivorous Plant Society, The Civic Club, Auckland, 22 March 2021

March 25, 2021

Aliens, ghosts, monsters and marimbas all feature in a Carnivorous Plant Society concert. FRANCES CHAN loves every moment, and you will too.

Carnivorous Plant Society. Photo: JUSTIN REDDING

When the apocalypse comes, I want Carnivorous Plant Society to be the last band standing. Their toe-tapping cinematic jazzscapes deliver the kind of chutzpah needed to get through any dark times. Just the sheer amount of instruments on stage is a serotonin-inducing sight. Usually a five-piece, CPS pulled out all the stops for this Auckland Arts Festival performance with special guests, creating a fruity nine-headed music-making amoeba.


Would you like to support our mission to bring intelligence, insight and great writing to entertainment journalism? Help to pay for the coffee that keeps our brains working and fingers typing just for you. Witchdoctor, entertainment for grownups. Your one-off (or monthly) $5 or $10 donation will support and help us keep producing quality content. It’s really easy to donate, just click the ‘Become a supporter’ button below.



Frontman Finn Scholes is the exemplar of a constantly moving membrane: on stage right he commands two banks of keyboards, a trumpet and a tuba; on stage left he’s a four-mallet (Gary) Burton-gripping vibraphonist and marimba player. He also draws and animates naïve comics to illustrate each song, which are projected behind the band. I don’t know which discipline informs the other, but the end result is a vibrant yet sinister world inhabited by amorphous aliens, ghosts and a hole-face monster, natch.

Carnivorous Plant Society. Photos: JUSTIN REDDING

In centre stage Siobhanne Thompson delights on the violin, vibraphone, vocals, pocket trumpet and percussion, while her partner and Finn’s brother Tam Scholes delivers a deft touch on guitar. The meat and potatoes of this piquant platter are Alistair Deverick on drums and Cass Basil on bass and vocals, ably assisted by seasoned percussionist Michael Barker (The John Butler Trio, Split Enz).

The bona fide ‘Carnies’ in the audience got the chance to show their allegiance early in ‘Phantom Finger’, a Mexican mariachi fantasy with floaty violin and a flawless finger-pickin’ guitar solo. When Finn’s trumpet chorus ascends to the skies, it’s the cue for us to holler and howl like crazy – boy, did that feel good.

Zappa met Herb Alpert next in ‘Magic Misty Land’, where the vibraphone and trumpet drive a slower melody, enhanced by guitar effects and culminating in a tender trumpet solo. Finn’s matching visuals showed the cautionary tale of a man being teleported into said land, “getting eaten by a giant in red undies and spewed out. It’s a vomit festival.”

The full complement was present for ‘It Followed Them’, a ballad about a fishing trip gone wrong. Hollie Fullbrook of Tiny Ruins – who appears on two CPS albums – contrasted her delicate vocals with Tim Stewart from Hopetoun Brown (playing the sea monster in fetching camo-net drapery). Fellow Hopetouner Nick Atkinson added the dulcet bass clarinet and Finn’s marimba laid a mellow (sea)bed. Tim’s main instruments, trumpet and trombone, together with Nick on either baritone or tenor sax and Finn on trumpet, strike up a formidable horn section, which led most of the arrangements.

Carnivorous Plant Society. Photos: JUSTIN REDDING

CPS may favour the slow grooves but these are lusciously layered, for example, with ethereal vocals by Hollie, Siobhanne and Cass and eerie waning horns on ‘Chambers And Cathedrals’ (a ghost love story that turns parasitic) and the enigmatic-sounding ‘Slave Song’ with Siobhanne rattling a chain and jazzy brass jabs building in intensity. ‘Bob Dylan’ honours the spaghetti western with tremolo guitar, a forlorn violin and rolling drum brushes. ‘Car Dance’ could have been on the Twin Peaks soundtrack with its languorous sway and Hollie’s dreamy vocals;  however, it raced away with an upbeat marimba and guitar-fuelled ending.

Carnivorous Plant Society. Photos: JUSTIN REDDING

Finn’s organ and the Hopetoun boys found the funk on ‘Sex Guru’ and the 60s-styled ‘Francoise Hardy’, with the baritone sax and drums breaking out. My favourite might be ‘Take’, a song about losing our natural environment, which opens with fast-arpeggiating solo marimba, inspired by Steve Reich. Cass leads the vocals and the band slowly crescendos to those beautiful horns again.

Speaking of beautiful, the girls made an effort in snazzy jumpsuits – Cass in grass green, Hollie in floral and Siobhanne in leafy motif (I see what you all did there).

Carnivorous Plant Society. Photos: JUSTIN REDDING

The odd man out in their repertoire is ‘The Bogan And The Kid’, a comedic ballad reminiscent of Flight Of The Conchords or Hugh Laurie, but it’s a rousing ditty with full harmonies and fitting for an encore. Ending on a sonorous high, we were dazzled by six horns blasting through ‘Down The Misty Hill’ (Alistair and Tam adding their chops on trombone and flugelhorn, respectively). The creepy creatures of Finn’s imaginary dystopia faded from the screen to reveal a sunrise in a rainbow-coloured sky. We actually survived the apocalypse and are now Carnies of the future.

  • Carnivorous Plant Society performed as part of the Auckland Arts Festival. A rejigged quartet version of the band is undertaking a 21-date Arts On Tour NZ to rural and small towns nationwide from 27 March to 25 April 2021, so get amongst!

Set list:

  1. Love In An Apocalypse II
  2. Phantom Finger
  3. Misty Magic Land
  4. It Followed Them
  5. Don’t Go Outside
  6. Magic Eye
  7. Chambers And Cathedrals
  8. The Boy
  9. Sex Guru
  10. Car Dance
  11. Take
  12. Slave Song
  13. Agatha
  14. Bob Dylan
  15. Francoise Hardy
  16. Temple Kiss
  17. Carp In A Pond


  1. The Bogan And The Kid
  2. Down The Misty Hill


Avatar photo

Frances is now into her fourth decade of editing, writing and proofreading for books and magazines in the fields of children’s education, music and film, architecture and design, fashion, travel and sometimes even her favourite subject – rugby. Other discernible likes include hosting the 95bFM Jazz Show, DJing, baking, biking and bashing the drums.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Give a little to support Witchdoctor's quest to save high quality independent journalism. It's easy and painless! Just donate $5 or $10 to our PressPatron account by clicking on the button below.

Witchdoctor straight to your inbox every 2nd week


Advance Paris - Designed with French flair. Amplifiers, Streamers, CD players and more
Apple Watch Series 6 review
Previous Story

Apple Watch Series 6 REVIEW

Next Story

Government shakes up property market – What does it mean?

Latest from Concerts

Perfect Pitch

Twenty-five years ago GARY STEEL met up with wayward Kiwi electronic duo Pitch Black for a nice chat. A NZ Music Month special.

Mike Oldfield with bells on

Mike Oldfield’s Tubular Bells is over 50 years old but still sounds fresh. GARY STEEL chats with the man behind the upcoming Auckland performance

Icehouse, 40 years ago

It’s not often you get to interview Iva Davies (Icehouse) and Jo Camilleri (Jo Jo Zep) at the same time. GARY STEEL did way
Go toTop