February 1, 2018
2 mins read
Witchdoctor Rating
  • 8/10
    - 8/10


The Good Doctor [Lightbox]

ANDREW JOHNSTONE reviews a new series about an autistic savant surgeon. Believe it or not.

“My name is Shaun and I am a Surgical Resident at St Bonaventure Hospital in San Jose,” Shaun Murphy explains to anyone and everyone who crosses his path. He also likes apples, and might throw that in without further prompting.

He speaks in a flat monotone and uses body language awkwardly. His behaviour turns erratic when stressed and he often misconstrues simple social situations. People sometimes feel uncomfortable in his presence and when the penny drops might say something like: “I am not letting this freak anywhere near my son/sister/husband,” as the case may be.

When things get messy the surgical team are at a loss as to what to do next, Shaun stares off into space and a whole lot of complex graphics appear above his head. That’s his unusual brain making some unusual moves. Then he explains his idea. The lead surgeon might shake his head in doubt but Shaun’s logic is often hard to ignore and mostly they do as he suggests and another life is saved.

Shaun is an autistic savant and British actor Freddy Highmore (Bates Motel) has put a lot of effort into creating a convincing description of the condition. “You’re arrogant,” he says to his dismissive surgical superior early on in the series. “Do I have to be arrogant to be a good surgeon?”

From Shaun’s perspective it’s a legitimate inquiry. He’s had a rough ride through life and as a result all he wants to do is help others and if being arrogant will make him a better doctor then so be it. Fortunately, he has friends looking out for him and they mostly set him right.

Based on a huge South Korean hit, the owner of the rights (South Korean actor Daniel Dae Kim) had a hard time getting any traction for the concept in the USA, but eventually Sony and the ABC network came on board and the result was one of the biggest broadcast hits of 2017.

I have seen Season One, which is middle of the road, somewhere between Grey’s Anatomy and House (without the crazed sociopathy) and with a good dose of Doogie Howser MD laid over on top. The House comparison is especially pertinent as that show’s creator David Shore, is in charge of The Good Doctor. His other credits include NYPD Blue and Sneaky Pete, all well-written and good quality stuff.

The surgeons are all drop dead gorgeous and there is some shagging in the supply cupboard (not Shaun – such things bewilder him, and he is more interested in acquiring a big screen TV) as well as a lot of the usual human nonsense – ambition, hierarchical politics and jealousy – all of it baffling to the good Dr Murphy. Otherwise, the show does a nice job of exploring subjects like bullying, prejudice and sexual harassment. That last one is especially relevant given the current climate in the entertainment business.

I laughed and I cried and was often moved. The first season is thoughtful and neatly paced and its only real flaw is a tendency toward overt sentimentality. Otherwise, the central theme of autism is well pitched and the message is that while people with the condition are a bit ‘different’ they can actually mostly get along quite well with a little understanding and empathy. Perhaps that is a bit simplistic but I am no expert so I will leave that one open for discussion.

The Good Doctor starts streaming on Lightbox from Friday Feb 2.


* The Internet and ‘TV on Demand’ has revolutionised the way we watch TV shows. No longer beholden to television networks and their programming whims and scheduling, we can watch back-to-back episodes of new and old shows to our heart’s content without those annoying advertisements interrupting the narrative flow. TV viewing has suddenly become more accessible, democratic and a hell of a lot more fun. ANDREW JOHNSTONE scours the available channels and finds the best of the best, so you don’t have to.


Andrew Johnstone is Witchdoctor's Film & TV Editor. He also writes and produces music (with creative partner, legendary Waikato music producer Zed Brookes), is an avid gardener, former dairy farmer and food industry sales person. When he isn't making up stories he writes about the stories he sees on television and at the cinema. He is also fascinated by politics (the social democratic sort) and describes The Universal Declaration of Human Rights as his religion.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Give a little to support Witchdoctor's quest to save high quality independent journalism. It's easy and painless! Just donate $5 or $10 to our PressPatron account by clicking on the button below.

Witchdoctor straight to your inbox every 2nd week


Advance Paris - Designed with French flair. Amplifiers, Streamers, CD players and more
Previous Story


Next Story


Latest from Film & TV

Furiosa: A Mad Max Saga

ASHTON BROWN finds the latest instalment of the Mad Max franchise not quite up to scratch but still worth a look-see despite the non-appearance
Go toTop