BACK IN JANUARY 2011, I wrote of The Puddle album, Playboys Of The Bush: “George Henderson’s lyrics and delivery grab you by the short and curlies: unmoderated, direct, contentious, outrageous… I’m knocked out by talent this raw, art that doesn’t concede to any commercial or aesthetic considerations… Like a punk-edged Syd Barrett who has lost, then found himself again (while remaining seriously askew), George Henderson and his Puddle have managed to squeeze out a short but potent work.”
I’m quoting myself because it’s no less true of Secret Holiday/Victory Blues, and I can’t think of a better way to write it.
Again, there’s psychedelic rock at the heart of much of this album, but nothing is straight down the line in Henderson’s world.
For instance, ‘Didn’t Even Notice You Were Gone’ is a country satire that asks: “Why are the rats so bold?” He’s not afraid to try his hand at a ballad, and paste synthesiser and violin on the same song. Henderson is a striking personality, and that comes through in his lyrics. On ‘Tender Validation’, for instance, he’s not shy in talking about his own lack of discretion, valour or sophistication when it comes to matters of the heart. It’s great, and honest.
I wish, however, that Fishrider’s budget extended to a producer, and rehearsal time, and someone to sweat over the arrangements. It’s just all so shambolic that the listener is that much less likely to take Henderson’s work seriously. And that’s the pity of it. GARY STEEL
Sound = 2.5/5
Music = 3.5/5
The Puddle – Secret Holiday/Victory Blues (Fishrider) CD REVIEW
Latest from Music
30 Years Ago: Michael Nyman’s unexpected chart success
Michael Nyman is not a pop star. Yet his soundtrack to The Piano has landed him in the commercial marketplace, writes GARY STEEL
1001 Albums You Must Die Before You Hear – Macho Man Randy Savage
MATT KELLY loves records by washed-up wrestlers but Randy Savage's attempt to musically spar with Hulk Hogan is an unmitigated disaster.
40 Years Ago: Hammond Gamble
GARY STEEL chats with Hammond Gamble about his Allstars Sing The Blues with Beaver.
1001 Albums You Must Die Before You Hear #100: Metallica with Lou Reed – Lulu
MATT KELLY somehow manages to listen to 90 minutes of possibly the worst collaborative album by major rock figures ever made.
Live Shows From Way Back – The Chills
GARY STEEL revisits his short review of a Chills gig in a pub one dark night in Wellington back in 1984.