The early to mid-1980s was a weird time for poor Neil Young, who changed labels just in time to break away from the styles he had made his own. The electronic-oriented album Trans just about sunk his career, and the new record company ended up getting its knickers in a twist, contending that Young had sabotaged them by providing such unlikely material.
Not to worry, by ’84 he was touring with a bunch of old Nashville session musicians, and calling them the International Harvesters. The songs and material were as safe as houses.
This album features a live performance from that tour, and the playing – by the likes of Spooner Oldham and Ben Keith – is mighty fine. But it also feels like Young is taking a between-labels hiatus; cruising between record deals and playing a bunch of low-key country tunes, perhaps as a way of retreating from the threatened litigation.
Who knows, but the result is dull. Died-in-the-wool country fans may find merit in it, and there are a few songs that never made it to vinyl or compact disc, but it’s really one for completists only.
The recording, while adequate, fails to resolve the individual instruments on these performances to a satisfactory audio conclusion, so that while it makes for pleasant background, it doesn’t benefit from turning up loud and dissecting it with an analytical hi-fi system. GARY STEEL
Music = 3
Sound = 2.5
Neil Young – A Treasure (Reprise/Warner) CD REVIEW
Latest from Music
Random Vinyl Play: This 1969 debut is an unheralded classic
In a new column, GARY STEEL dips into his vinyl racks. Today it’s the tasty debut by UK psychedelic band Caravan.
30 Years Ago: Michael Nyman’s unexpected chart success
Michael Nyman is not a pop star. Yet his soundtrack to The Piano has landed him in the commercial marketplace, writes GARY STEEL
1001 Albums You Must Die Before You Hear – Macho Man Randy Savage
MATT KELLY loves records by washed-up wrestlers but Randy Savage's attempt to musically spar with Hulk Hogan is an unmitigated disaster.
40 Years Ago: Hammond Gamble
GARY STEEL chats with Hammond Gamble about his Allstars Sing The Blues with Beaver.
1001 Albums You Must Die Before You Hear #100: Metallica with Lou Reed – Lulu
MATT KELLY somehow manages to listen to 90 minutes of possibly the worst collaborative album by major rock figures ever made.