WELL, IT’S A long way from Britpop, but then, so is Gorillaz.
Dr Dee, however, is an almost stupendously – preposterously? – ambitious project for someone whose career to date, apart from some canny lyric writing and some careful choices of band mates, amounts to a whole lot of monotone mumbling.
Apparently it’s tangentially connected to an opera about a certain John Dee, a Renaissance-era astronomer and advisor to royalty. “Fascinating!” you may well mutter, under your breath.
Unfortunately, there’s no actual story/libretto, and it really just comes across like 17 often excruciatingly arty vignettes. It’s never less than eccentric. ‘Apple Carts’ comes across like some perverted idea of Elizabethan minstrelsy, but the very next song, ‘O Spirit, Animate Us’, is like a prayer rendered by counter tenors and ancient music consort; a liturgy. There are members of the BBC Philharmonic and vocal group Palace Voices. There are harpsichords, chimes, oboes, and austere operatic bits that sometimes stick in the craw. Oh, and organ.
Albarn should probably be applauded for having the temerity, in the conservative climate of modern pop, to attempt something as outlandish as this, and there are some genuinely touching, lovely moments. But it would have needed to have some kind of narrative or musical arc to make it comprehensible to one’s senses.
The problem with an album like this is that it’s almost impossible to get to grips with. Spend a lot of time with it, and it may get under your skin, or just cause a rash. I don’t feel inclined to risk it. GARY STEEL
Music = 3/5
Sound = 3.5/5
Latest from Music
Aldous Harding: The lost interview
Especially for New Zealand Music Month GARY STEEL disinters a 10-year-old interview with Aldous Harding conducted at the time of her debut album.
1001 Albums You Must Die Before You Hear – The Small Faces
MATT KELLY is aghast at how far this formerly great band had fallen by the time of its reunion albums and explains their sad
Icehouse, 40 years ago
It’s not often you get to interview Iva Davies (Icehouse) and Jo Camilleri (Jo Jo Zep) at the same time. GARY STEEL did way
Hi-Fi Show Report: AXPONA
OWEN HARRIS moseyed along to the largest hi-fi show in the USA and instead of just taking in endless rooms of product took time
Random Vinyl Play: This 1969 debut is an unheralded classic
In a new column, GARY STEEL dips into his vinyl racks. Today it’s the tasty debut by UK psychedelic band Caravan.