BASED ON A 70-year-old Graham Greene novel, and adapted from a 1947 movie, this new version of Brighton Rock was reimagined to have occurred in 1964, director Rowan Joffeโs bright idea to combine the nasty antics of a bunch of thugs with the milieu of rioting that came to pass when the seaside resort became a warzone between the mods and the rockers.
Dumb idea: the beautifully-restored scooters and the extras running around in the de rigeur uniforms of the two opposing youth cultures just get in the way of the actual story, without adding anything of consequence, and help to make this historic recreation look faked.
Despite that enormous error of judgment, thereโs much to recommend Brighton Rock. Andrea Riseborough is brilliant as the appealingly ditzy teen waitress who falls for the abominable young criminal (played by Sam Riley), presumably because her achingly dull situation calls for a true love fantasy, regardless of consequences. Helen Mirren is also effortlessly great as the dining room manager who tries to save the girl from her fate.
There are excellent scenes and bravura touches in this โqualityโ English drama, but is hampered by focusing almost exclusively on Rileyโs character, Pinkie Brown, who lacks even a shred of human decency. Had the film instead centred on Riseboroughโs character, Rose, we would have felt the noose tighten as Pinkie engineered for her to fall in love with him just so he could make sure that โ as the only witness to a murder he committed โ she would never tell.
The conclusion, when it comes, is one of those โwhateverโ moments, and you end up wishing the film had been steered more decisively so that you actually felt something at its inevitable tragedy.
Some viewers will, of course, enjoy the fine performances, and they will also doubtless enjoy the disc of extras, including a โmaking ofโ, interviews with directors and cast, deleted scenes and several other mini-features. The film itself also has the near-obligatory director audio commentary. GARY STEEL
Film = 3 stars
Sound = 3.5 stars
Vision = 3.5 stars
Extras = 4 stars
Brighton Rock (Madman) DVD REVIEW
Latest from Music
Wellington in the ’80s through the lens of an outsider music group
GARY STEEL reviews a new book thatโs not only the story of an extraordinary band, label and scene, but an alternative history of Wellington
Dance around the world with Corben Simpson
He won a Silver Scroll award in 1971. He sang for Blerta. He recorded an album in bed. After more than 50 years Corben
The format wars suck
GARY STEEL has been thinking about vinyl vs. streaming vs. compact discs (etc) and just wants it all to stop.
Who you jiving with that cosmic debris? Zappa’s Apostrophe (โ) at 50
Frank Zappaโs most popular album gets a chunky six-disc elaboration. GARY STEEL wonders whether it warrants the attention.
World’s Worst Records – Alison Gold’s Chinese Food
Our expert on the worst of the worst, the honourable MATT KELLY, gets stuck into a very dubious release that verges on culturally insensitive.